Sunday, February 16, 2014

Prose Close Reading Passage Essay #2

What people want to know, whether they ask it directly or not, is how I fell in love with Stuart and married him, then fell in love with Oliver and married him, all within as short a space as is legally possible.  Well the answer is I did just that I did just that.  I don’t especially recommend you try it, but I promise it’s possible.  Emotionally as well as legally.
I genuinely loved Stuart.  I fell in love with him straightforwardly, simply.  We got on, the sex worked, I loved the fact he loved me—and that was it.  And then, after we were married, I fell in love with Oliver, not simply at all, but very complicatedly, entirely against my instincts and my reason.  I refused it, I resisted it, I felt intensely guilty.   I also felt intensely excited, intensely alive, intensely sexy.  No, as a matter of fact we didn’t ‘have an affair,’ as the saying goes.  Just because I’m half French people start muttering ménage à trois.  It wasn’t remotely like that.  It felt much more primitive for a start.  And besides, Oliver and I didn’t sleep with one another until Stuart and I had separated.  Why are people such experts on what they don’t know about? 
The point is you can love two people, one after the other, one interrupting the other, like I did.  You can love them in different ways.  And it doesn’t mean one love is true and the other is false.  That’s what I wish I could have convinced Stuart.  I loved each of them truly.  You don’t believe me?  Well, it doesn’t matter, I no longer argue the case.  I just say: it didn’t happen to you , did it?  It happened to me. 

And looking back, I’m surprised it doesn’t happen more often.  Long afterwards my mother said, apropos of some other emotional situation, I can’t remember, some twosome or threesome, she said ‘The heart has been made tender, and that is dangerous.’  I could see what she meant.  Being in love makes you liable to fall in love.  Isn’t that a terrible paradox?  Isn’t that a terrible truth? (Barnes 15-17).


No comments:

Post a Comment